How Some Cat Pictures Increased My Email Subscriber Confirmations

47 Intelligent Opinions, Leave Yours.

my cat

They say the ancient Egyptians worshipped cats. I wonder what future humans will say about us when they examine our Internet servers!

We all know cats are popular.

But, as I found out the other day, they can even help you get more email subscribers, brand loyalty and trust.

Yes, I’m being serious.

I’m not talking about posting cat pictures on your entirely unrelated business or health blog though. That would be mental. But I literally did use some images of my cat on Blog Tyrant to boost my email subscriber rate.

I’ll show you how.

NOTE: This post contains some affiliate links. If you purchase a package by clicking from this page I’ll earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thanks for supporting the site.

A problem in the email subscriber confirmation process

So I was sitting with my beautiful fiancée (who is also in the marketing field) mucking around on Blog Tyrant trying to create a new landing page for an upcoming advertising campaign.

She signed up to my mailing list and then said, “Ummm… that’s pretty annoying that your confirmation email goes straight to my spam folder.

Yes, yes it is.

Checking my email subscriber stats I discovered that a large portion of email subscribers weren’t confirming their email address – a very important step in the double opt-in process.

confirmation pending

The above is a screenshot from my AWeber account showing a huge block of recent subscribers who signed up and then didn’t confirm their email address.

This is bad.

Now, there are some people who have been saying lately that AWeber mail outs are getting delivered to the spam folder a lot more. I don’t know if this is true but I can assure you I am looking into it very seriously as the majority of my business (other than the blog) is done via email marketing.

So what did I do?

Using custom page to ask people to confirm

Up until now I had just used AWeber’s default page that asks people to confirm.

I had always assumed that it did the trick even though it was unbranded and looked nothing like my blog.

Well, last week I created a custom thank you page which people get re-directed to as soon as they enter their email address into a form on my blog.

email cat

As you can see, it uses a picture of my cat to grab attention and keep the new subscriber on my site. It then uses an arrow and some text to explain to people that they need to confirm their email address and, importantly, that the email in question may go to their spam folder.

The result?

I’m starting to see a lot more people confirm their email address right away.

That means more people actively on my list, receiving my Follow Up sequence and receiving notifications about new posts like this one.

How do you make a custom confirmation page?

If you use a service like AWeber it should be pretty easy.

First, just make a Page in WordPress like mine that explains what email subscribers need to do.

Then, in AWeber you just click on the sign up form that you want to edit and then under the second step in the editor field just find the section below.

confirmation

Select the Custom option and then paste in the URL of the page you want people to see once they’ve entered their email.

NOTE: This is a different page to the “Success” page that people see after they have confirmed their email address. This one comes before.

Too early to be sure?

I only did this little experiment last week so it is perhaps too early to tell if the increase in confirmations is entirely due to the new confirmation page.

For example, it could be that I have a different type of traffic this week and that those subscribers are more adept at finding the confirmation email.

I still like to share these things with you though because I believe that it’s much better for you to try it out on your own blog than waiting to see whether it works for me.

And by publishing ideas like this I can get feedback from you on the process as well as any other similar idea that you might have had.

This is what makes the Tyrant Troops community so valuable – the comment threads are always filled with amazing ideas, test results and conversation.

So I’ll keep publishing half-baked experiments!

The importance of simplicity online

This type of thing really reminds me of how important it is to keep online processes simple.

A lot of people who read your blog are entirely new to the concept and things like email subscriptions can seem daunting.

Even companies like Amazon are struggling to simplify their process to keep shopping cat abandonment down.

So what can we do?

  • Explain the process
    Make sure you explain the process clearly to potential subscribers so they know what to expect.
  • Keep the branding the same
    As I found out, keeping the branding the same can help people to realize that they’re on the same site and just following the regular process.
  • Give reminders
    At the bottom of my emails I now have a little reminder that tells people that they’re receiving this email because they subscribed to Blog Tyrant. I borrowed this from Jon Morrow and it seems to be a good way to stop people hitting the spam button because they’re forgotten.

We spend a lot of time writing really high quality content, working on SEO and crafting the perfect emails. It’s super important, therefore, to make sure we’re not wasting all that hard working by having gaps in the sign up process.

What about you?

Have you had a problem getting people to confirm their email address when they subscribe to your blog? What did you do about it? If you have any stories or perhaps and other ideas about this I’d love to hear from you.

Please leave a comment.

All photos by Ramsay who spends way too much time alone talking to his cat.



Ramsay WROTE THIS

Did you enjoy this post? Why not subscribe for future stuff and get it sent directly to your inbox - it's totally free and doesn't happen often?

LEARN MORE

47 Comments... Leave yours.

  • Leanne Cole

    Okay, I already followed, but I had to start following you on Instagram because of the cat photos, very cute.


    1. Ramsay

      Ha ha. He is awesome!


      1. Leanne Cole

        Our cat has his own facebook page, Tiddles Cole


        1. Ramsay

          Ha ha ha. The net sure loves cats.


  • Beth

    Brilliant! I have plenty of photos of my cat I could use.


    1. Ramsay

      Ha ha. I feel like I might start a “cats on unrelated blogs” movement.


  • Jenny | Floppycats.com

    Just imagine if you shared Cino (if my memory serves me correctly) on Floppycats.com as Ragdoll of the Week – all those wannabe cat bloggers would have someone new to follow for tips and tricks.

    Of course, I think this idea is brilliant – any Ragdoll cat with eyes like that and a blaze like that will attract attention and demand sign ups.


    1. Ramsay

      Oh yeah I totally forgot I was going to do that!

      Let me look at it now.


  • Deborah

    Your cat has awesome eyes! ^^

    Thank you for the tip!


    1. Ramsay

      Yeah he’s very cute.

      Thanks Deborah.


  • Averil

    Sorry Ramsay, If I wasn’t an already loyal reader if yours and I saw your pic of your cat I would out right reject it for the plain fact there was a cat. Not everyone likes pictures of cats. I feel there is way too many pictures of those dastardly felines. I even have a Pinterest board called “I hate cats!” Lol but other than that, great post!


    1. Ramsay

      You take down that board right now! Ha ha.

      I’m comfortable with the fact that you have to like cats to read Blog Tyrant. ;-)


  • Darius

    Great Post Ramsay! I noticed when I get your email newsletter that it shows your first and last name. Is it better to show your name or to show your brand’s name? I was planning to test that.


    1. Ramsay

      Hey Darius.

      It used to say Blog Tyrant but now I’m testing my real name. Open rates seem to be slightly up but it’s still too early to tell.

      Most of the big names Glen Allsopp, Jon Morrow, Pat Flynn, etc. all use their names.


      1. Darius

        Okay I thought it used to say BlogTyrant. Thanks for the response.


  • Fran Civile

    I would never in a million years thought of sending an aWeber request for confirmation with pictures of cats and I’m amazed that it seemed to work for you.

    I wonder how many sign-ups decided to not confirm because of the cat photos.

    Fran


    1. Ramsay

      I think it’s more about making it seem familiar and friendly than anything to do with the cats.


  • Kulwant Nagi

    I think I will have to buy one cat for increasing my conversion.. ha ha..

    Another awesome article with complete action plan. I was thinking to add custom confirmation page on my blog as well but due to heavy work load I was not able to do it.

    This article for sure going to force me to take action today itself.

    Thanks for the share.


    1. Ramsay

      Ha ha. Glad you enjoyed.


  • Dayo | Audacity2Lead.com

    Hi Ramsay,

    I use Mailchimp for my mailing list. Though I kind of focus my content on helping Nigerians blog with excellence, I would like to know if I can customize my signup process in Mailchimp like that too (not with cats though, ha ha ha).

    I tried creating a new page for the sign up in my WordPress dashboard, the page seems to be appearing on the Menu, how do I hide that to show only for Subscriptions?

    You have schooled me in blogging. Keep it up!


    1. Ramsay

      Find a plugin called “exclude from navigation”.


      1. Dayo | Audacity2Lead.com

        Oh okay. Thank you. I’ll do that soon


  • sara woodward

    Hi Ramsey, Does your cat get paid the minimum wage of freshly cooked chicken? I work for a web designer and we are doing a similar thing with our cute little Jug (jack russell/pug). Hattie works wonders. Landing pages – you would not believe how many pages I come across with those immortal words ‘please bare with us’ rather than ‘bear with us’. So, is asking your clients to ‘get naked’ the way to go! Love your landing page and your cat. Have a good day. Woody


    1. Ramsay

      Ha ha ha. Bearly contained myself with that comment.


  • Paul Back

    Hey Ramsay

    I am going through my subscription messages now – just changed from Mailchimp to Aweber.

    I would have thought that emails with images in them would decrease sign up rate – good to hear its helping you out.

    I think it adds personality and that can only be a good thing.


    1. Ramsay

      It’s not an email.


      1. Paul Back

        Sorry my bad :) – didn’t realise it was on the subscription confirmation page.

        Makes more sense now, and I think personalizing that page in a way that is congruent with your style / blog would be beneficial for people to follow through.

        It would grab attention and show some personality – I am playing around with the concept myself but through a personal message, I hadn’t thought to use any images.


  • liz@lifedreaming

    Hey Ramsay
    Love your cat – very very beautiful.

    My gravatar is a pic of me and my Coco dog. It’s an image I have on my Linked In profile and people love it. One of my most popular posts was 30 things I learnt about life from my dog! I’m turning that post into a slideshow!

    I agree that it gives people a glimpse into the person behind the brand and I love my Coco dog.

    By the way – I got a customer to my Life Dreaming from this fab blog. Cool people follow the Blog Tyrant.

    Have a great week Ramsay.

    Liz


    1. liz@lifedreaming

      just saw that my gravatar is my LD logo. Coco dog and me are on other social media though!


      1. Ramsay

        Glad you got a customer from here! That’s awesome!


  • Marc

    I have been using AWeber for a few years and I’m very happy with their service, but I had a similar experience with delivery a few months ago. I started a new list with a new site and the confirmation emails weren’t being delivered. They weren’t going to the spam folder like yours are, but they just weren’t being delivered at all. AWeber support tried to help me with it, but their suggestions weren’t working. I tried GetResponse with the same email address, subject line, and email body message, and I’ve had no problems with the delivery.

    I still use AWeber with one of my other sites and I don’t have any issues with that account, so I’m not anti-AWeber. But if you are having trouble keeping emails out of the spam folder you may want to do some testing with a free trial at GetResponse.


    1. Ramsay

      Hey Marc.

      A few people have been telling me this. I’m thinking about doing a test for the next mailout.

      Thanks for the reminder.


  • Wendy

    I love this idea! I’m currently working on a niche blog and this is so genius, it blew my mind.

    I haven’t really fallen in love with too many confirmation pages (at least not quite like this), but I have witnessed a very hilarious “unsubscribe” page. I will paraphrase as much as I can. Essentially, after you subscribe you see a “live” video of a guy in an office and you have the option to “punish (Bob)” to show your grief with the blog. Obviously, I chose to “punish (Bob)” and as soon as I did, a man came by with a shoe and hit (Bob) on the head. This made (Bob) very sad and then the video asks, “Feel bad? Re-subscribe to make it up to (Bob)!”

    I didn’t like the blog at all, so I didn’t re-subscribe, but this was just genius to me. So simple, yet very impactful!


    1. Ramsay

      Ha ha. Poor Bob! There are some funny error pages out there as well. Thanks for sharing Wendy, that’s awesome.


  • chris

    Here is the top text of my “please confirm” page:

    “Almost finished…
    An email has been dispatched to your inbox.
    You MUST click the link in that email to confirm your email address.
    Once confirmed, you can DOWNLOAD THE FREE EBOOKS and be subscribed to the newsletter.”

    It’s a subtle reminder of “you’ll get the free ebooks as long as you do this one last step.”

    Once they click the confirmation link, it takes them to a Thank You page.

    If anyone is using Mailchimp, the settings are under your list’s form options.

    *This entire comment contains no deep insight, no gold nuggets of information, and no cat pictures. Meow.


    1. Ramsay

      Go on! Add a cat. ;-)


  • Robin Hallett

    Spot on Ramsay! I too was noticing that at least 30 of my subscriptions went unconfirmed each month. Drove me crazy. Then I made the custom ‘almost finished check your email’ page on my website and it has taken care of the problem. I do not have a cat but use an awesome drawing I did- we are a visual culture… P.s. I noticed the switch from blog tyrant to Ramsay. I’m a fan of this. Makes you more human in my eyes, and I find I’m reading more posts :-)


    1. Ramsay

      Hey Robin.

      Thanks for mentioning the change to my real name. I was hoping it would have that effect. Appreciate the feedback.


      1. Robin Hallett

        Woot! Awesome!


  • Mark

    Great blog article Ramsay! As someone who is just getting going building my list I want to make sure no new followers fall into this “crack.” Fol lowering your advice I already set up my aweber acct so this should be easy to make the needed adjustments with.


    1. Ramsay

      Glad it helped!


  • Emily Journey

    Love it! You wrote ‘shopping CAT abandonment’ instead of cart.
    You did that on purpose to see if I’d notice. ;-)


    1. Ramsay

      YES! Someone read the post!


  • Elena

    Ramsay, I am blown away that you are just now utilizing custom landing pages for email sign up. For those of us who do not use Aweber, we can also create a custom landing page on our site, and then, depending on the provider, link to it as the second step of the sign up process, which will take care of branding, since the page is hosted on our site (inside the template we use).


    1. Ramsay

      Yeah I have them at every other stage but just not that instant “confirm your email” page. Never thought it made a difference.


As mentioned on...